News

Location: Home  /  News  /  Industry Trends
The differences between pneumatic actuators and electric actuators
Date:2026-06-08 12:00:00 Author:Zhejiang Yonghao Valve Co., Ltd.

I. Different power supply conditions


Pneumatic actuators use compressed air as the driving energy source. On-site, a complete gas supply system including air compressors, storage tanks, and air source triplex units is required. The gas pressure is used to push the piston or diaphragm to complete mechanical actions. Without a stable gas source, the actuator cannot operate.


Electric actuators rely on industrial frequency alternating current power or DC stabilized power supply for driving. They only need to lay out power and control cables and do not need to add fluid power supporting equipment. There is no requirement for gas pipeline layout. Once the power supply is in place, they can work independently.


II. Different structural composition and operation and maintenance costs


The body structure of pneumatic actuators is simple. It mainly consists of cylinder, piston, spring, output shaft, and is equipped with solenoid valves and air source filtration and pressure reduction components. There are no precision circuit boards or motor windings inside. The components are durable, and daily maintenance only requires regular drainage of gas source water accumulation and cleaning of filter elements. The overall maintenance cost is relatively low.


Electric actuators integrate drive motors, reduction gears, position sensors, main control circuit boards, and limit protection elements. There are many electrical precision components. Long-term operation is prone to line aging and electronic component failure. Fault repair requires professional electricians to operate. The comprehensive cost of spare parts replacement and operation is higher.


III. Different explosion-proof and hazardous working condition adaptability


The entire pneumatic actuator has no electrical sparking components. The gas-driven process does not have the risk of ignition by an electric spark. It inherently has explosion-proof characteristics and is suitable for high-risk explosion-proof areas such as chemical oil gas, flammable and explosive steam, and dust workshops. No additional explosion-proof enclosures are required.


Ordinary electric actuators have arc hazards when the motor, contactors, and circuit boards are powered on. For flammable and explosive places, products with explosion-proof shell grades must be selected. The equipment procurement cost increases significantly, and the sealing parts of the explosion-proof shell need to be maintained regularly.


IV. Different output torque and overload protection characteristics


The output torque of pneumatic actuators can be adjusted according to the supply air pressure. When foreign objects cause obstruction in the valve, only the gas source pressure will be released, and no structural damage to the body will occur. It has a buffering and fault-tolerant capability, and has excellent resistance to mechanical jamming impacts.


Electric actuators have a fixed output torque. When the valve stem gets stuck during operation, it will directly increase the motor load. The equipment has an overheat and overload protection circuit that automatically stops the machine. If the protection device fails, the motor winding is prone to burning out and the transmission gear is likely to break.


V. Different adjustment accuracy and control performance


Conventional pneumatic actuators can only achieve two-position on-off control. After installing an electrical valve positioner, it can achieve opening degree adjustment. However, the adjustment accuracy is affected by the fluctuation of the gas source pressure and has average stability.


Adjustable electric actuators rely on an internal position feedback closed-loop circuit. They can precisely match 4-20mA, 0-10V standard analog signals. The opening degree positioning error is small, and it is not affected by external fluid pressure. The control accuracy of continuous regulation of flow and pressure is higher in such working conditions.


VI. Different response speed and start-stop characteristics


Pneumatic actuators have a fast gas conduction speed. The valve opening and closing actions are instantaneous and responsive. They are suitable for process pipelines that require rapid cutting and quick switching.


Electric actuators complete the action through mechanical transmission by the motor. There is a start-up and deceleration buffering process. The opening and closing actions are smooth and cannot achieve instantaneous rapid switching.


VII. Different safety reset logic in case of power failure and gas loss


Pneumatic spring reset type actuators automatically reset to the preset safe position (fully open or fully closed) after losing gas, meeting the requirements for safe shutdown in the process. Double-acting pneumatic actuators maintain the current valve opening degree after losing gas.


Electric actuators lock all mechanisms when power is lost and maintain the opening degree before the power cut. They do not have a self-resetting function. If a safe shutdown is required after power loss, additional auxiliary devices such as batteries and electromagnetic bypasses are needed.


Home
Products
Contact